CycleBetter.Com!

The G-Rant : Grant's Rants on Adventure Racing

“Without adventure, civilization is in full decay.” - Alfred North Whitehead

Rogaine Retrospective and Glow Sticks On CP Flags?

We ran a clinic and a night Rogaine this past weekend, and both went off well.  I always feel like there isn't enough time to cover everything I want to in these clinics . . . we originally planned a full weekend "adventure racing camp" where we'd have 2 days of interaction, instruction, and conclude with a 6 hour race at the end of the second day but like many of our grand schemes the demands of a real job and schedule issues prevented us from putting all the pieces together.  It's just as well, because I think 2 full days would burn out the participants so that by the end they wouldn't get nearly as much from it as from these shorter, more focussed clinics.

Anyway, the Rogaine was fun; you can check out the Rogaine results if you're curious.  The Richmond ASR team (two of my teammates for next weekend) really tore up the course but came back 5 minutes too late so, in dramatic fashion, Tim Dunkum from Richmond was the overall winner.  His team won the Sproute 2006 short-course, so he probably takes to this navigation stuff pretty quickly; he was also at the clinic earlier in the day, so maybe that helped.  Maybe.

More important than who won, the 30 or 40 people out there (teams in size from 2 to 5) all seemed to have fun and there were some smiling new faces along with the smiling old ones.  That's always cool. 

For the night orienteering, the classic orienteers out there would've liked to see glow sticks on the flags but I feel like that makes things fairly easy for the terrain that we're working with.  If we had more space, then glow sticks might make more sense.  We work hard to hang controls on significant features, especially at night, so that it isn't a complete easter egg hunt out there . . . but we don't want everyone to have a cake walk either.   It's always a balancing act.

What are your thoughts on night orienteering and illuminating CP flags (glow sticks, reflective tape, etc)?  I know official orienteering rules say glow sticks, but in the adventure races I've done the night orienteering never uses glow sticks to "give away" control locations.  For the Storm 2006, for example, we have no plans to light up the CPs for the night portion.



Comments

Eric - Richmond ASR said:

Since I can't run as fast as some teams, I like the harder/no glowstick option. One thing to note, we had close to a fullmoon on Saturday. During the 24hr race and the Storm 2006 the moon will be 1/4 or less. I'm hoping that only helps my team because of my Edy's addiction.

The hard part with night nav is being able to focus on the map and the land features without blinding oneself or one's teammate. ;-) Just ask any teammate of mine, I've blinded all of them at one point or another. Dough! The good news they get me back two fold because of my glasses.
# July 10, 2006 11:30 PM

Jim Weber said:

I went back and checked the astronomy charts for last year's Storm race...looks like the moon was full on the day of the race, but I can't really remember if it was out at night to help us with finding CPs or not (hey, it was a long day!). In the two night orienteering events I have done and in all of the night ARs I have done, I don't recall ever having glowsticks on on CP flags (though many of the AR CPs were manned, and those are usually easier to find than a glowstick anyway). With that said, I am a fan of challening navigation, so I'd vote for not using glowsticks. Of course, if you add a glowstick but then make the CP really hard (like putting it in a pit or deep in a re-entrant), you will probably achieve much the same result as if you did not use a glowstick but made the CP really easy (like putting it at a trail intersection or at a significant bend in a stream).
# July 11, 2006 4:08 PM

Jim Weber said:

I went back and checked the astronomy charts for last year's Storm race...looks like the moon was full on the day of the race, but I can't really remember if it was out at night to help us with finding CPs or not (hey, it was a long day!). In the two night orienteering events I have done and in all of the night ARs I have done, I don't recall ever having glowsticks on on CP flags (though many of the AR CPs were manned, and those are usually easier to find than a glowstick anyway). With that said, I am a fan of challening navigation, so I'd vote for not using glowsticks. Of course, if you add a glowstick but then make the CP really hard (like putting it in a pit or deep in a re-entrant), you will probably achieve much the same result as if you did not use a glowstick but made the CP really easy (like putting it at a trail intersection or at a significant bend in a stream).
# July 11, 2006 4:19 PM

MNewlon said:

Jim - I don't have astronomy charts but it was pretty close to a full moon.  When Wes and I went down Mockhorn Island to the blackout area we didn't use our headlamps at all.
                     -Morgan
# July 11, 2006 7:07 PM

Eric - Richmond ASR said:

On the way back from the blackout area we didn't use our headlamps.

Saturday was a little different because of tree cover and sometimes thick under brush. The moonlight didn't helpout as much as was the case at Mockhorn Island. For #4 & #5 you really had to be on it before you found it, at least from our approach.
# July 11, 2006 8:02 PM

Ginger said:

As a "classic" orienteer, I'm a big fan of reflective tape on the controls.  This doesn't make the controls any easier to find (ie, you still have to be looking at it to see it) but on the plus side, you actually CAN see the control when you're looking at it. Of course, on the topic of challenging navigation, I'm also a fan of actually placing the control IN the control circle, but that's another discussion :) Under no circumstances should a control be placed IN a pit-the idea is that once the team/individual has successfully navigated their way into the control circle, the mapped feature on which the control is placed should be more or less obvious. The "treasure hunt" mentality of many adventure racing (and orienteering) course setters serves no purpose other than to frustrate and confuse-especially among new individuals to the sport and rewards luck, not skill. In my opinion, glow sticks should only be used on beginner courses for orienteering, and on at least on occasion I've used them to mark a CP for an adventure race once all the volunteers manning the control had gone to bed. Of course, the tent, car, and folding chairs (not to mention the large "CP" sign) were probably much better giveaways.
# July 11, 2006 11:31 PM
Sign in | Join | Help

in Search

Google